Make your own free website on



Texas erects roadblock to GM online
State agency rules online car sales would violate a new state law.

By Margaret Kane, ZDNN
July 7, 1999 12:04 PM PT

A state agency in Texas has denied General Motors' plans to launch a Web site selling cars directly to consumers.

Is Texas behind the Internet curve? Add your comments to the bottom of this page.

The company was to begin a trial in Houston, but has been denied permission to sell cars in the state, according to a spokeswoman for the Texas Department of Transportation.

Officials at General Motors could not be reached for comment.

The Houston Chronicle reported today that GMs DriverSite business was all set to go offline. The program allows consumers to research cars and schedule a test drive online -- and then head out to a DriverSite store to make their purchase. GM had already built a store, installed a computer network and hired salespeople, the paper reported.

There are several car-selling sites online now, but most simply match up consumers with dealers. DriverSite consumers would instead be buying directly from the manufacturer.

That's where GM ran into a Texas-sized problem.

In conflict with state law
The state recently passed a bill prohibiting manufacturers from owning dealerships or acting as a dealer, the spokeswoman said. So GM's application for a license to sell cars in the state was denied.


Site to sell cars entirely online

ZDNet AchorDesk: Buying cars directly

Auto firms head online

GM can appeal the decision, the spokeswoman said.

This isn't GM's first venture online. The company currently operates a GMBuyPower site, which allows consumers to research a car and get a quote, which can be taken to a dealership.

And it's not the first time Texas and the cyberspace have collided. In January, a federal judge banned the sale of self-help legal software developed by Parsons Technology, saying it violated state law prohibiting the unauthorized practice of law.

See also: ZDNN's Internet section

Soooooooo ..... GM needs to clo... - MysticHeart
General Motors could get around... - Jon Arena
Ah, Texas. Much like my old hi... - Nathan Hartzell
Texas officals should realize t... - Brian Roberds
I disagree with the state of Te... - Tony Muckleroy
I'm a Texas and I'm ashamed tha... - Jack R. Stroman
I'm guessing that the car deale... - Trevor Williamson
As a new car salesman in Housto... - Gary Sonnenberg
Good for Texas! We have eight ... - Tom Downs
Only in Texas!!! This kind of a... - Dave H. Britt
The governmant of Texas is tryi... - Katrina Taggart
Any state in the Union has the ... - Roger L. Sigler
Why shouldn't people be able to... - Alberta Carter
It sounds good whenever you can... - Walt Lind
**IMPORTANT EDITORS NOTE - P... - Tammy Cavadias -ZDNN Talkback Sysop
Although any state has the righ... - Jonathan Hains
This seems like such a foolish ... - James Lamb
I beleive that the state law is... - R. King
If approved, GM should never be... - Lew Shaw
Texas is a paranoid, sick place... - Lawrence Bouett
Gary, Tom and others...Too bad ... - shawnk
Good for Texas? How about "Goo... - Igor Matlin
As unpopular as it may be, at l... - Charles Dayton
Texas did not do this to avoid ... - Michelle DeFrance
I can buy Viagra online, order ... - Steve Fraser
I was willing to go out-of-town... - Satisfied Customer
Good for GM! Trying to control ... - Kurtis J. VanderMolen
It sounds to me like buggy whip... - Richard Argentieri
I am glad that Texas took this ... - Timothy W. Davis
Imagine the epitome of American... - Kurtis J. VanderMolen
My only question is why just Ge... - Glenn Gilbreath Jr.
Texas has always stuck it to th... - Jan E. Goodman
I live in GA, and our state leg... - Jason West
Distribution channels are chang... - Dale R. Thompson
Remember this when the 2000 ele... - Greg Wathen
Yet another reason to not live ... - Mike Farnsworth
GM has every right to do as the... - Bryan Maher
It's interesting to watch peopl... - Steve Postlethwait
Let's see. People in Texas buy... - Scott Wagner
Tom Downs: If you can't compete... - Fred Hass
There should be room for price ... - J. J. Lowe
There is nothing worse than a c... - Doug Fowler
It seems to me that Texas is be... - Wendell Sexson
You folks seem to have an awful... - Dennis M Garland
to think that the next presiden... - J. Rodriguez
Elect George Bush Jr. president... - Michael Olenick
If this sort of thing is what s... - mark Ross
Although the Texan government m... - R Harmel
G.M. want's both Worlds. The... - Chuck Burnside
I think yall are missing an imp... - Nathan Hurst
It's a good law. The fact is, ... - Ken Baker
It would seem that certain rich... - Kendall W. Spurlock
That AMD dig made no sense. It... - Anthony Forte
You can thank the Texas Automot... - Scott
Seems to me that you will end u... - Glenn Sweet
Texas and other states should n... - Carolyn Buford
Any state in the Union has the ... - Chuck K.
Eliminating the middleman, and ... - Doris Kilbane
This is wrong of the state of T... - Roy Flowers
So why not just make it a progr... - Mark Lamb
As soon as GM figures out a way... - mike massey
If it is stupid, Texas will lea... - Tom Hall
I cannot agree with the Parson'... - Daniel Hauck
The question is: Was this a law... - Jim Taylor
Just like communist China, Texa... - Richard Peasel
So many things come to mind. 1... - Chuck Riess
Different from all others is wh... - Chris Trevino
I gotta say this. Texas has al... - Dave Bryant
Notes on the garbage. Any nati... - Dave Bryant
I thought Indiana was bad about... - Bud Thurber
Lawyers. Is there any scourge ... - big red
At first look, I'd normally be ... - Jim Ownby
if texas allows people to by n... - charlie vollbaum
Some interesting - Dave Basham
Good for Texas, I am against d... - Jeffrey J. Duffy
I find it interesting that, if ... - Dave Perso
My first impression is that thi... - Lee Quijano


Site to sell cars entirely online, a new Net venture backed by Michael Dell, plans to bypass car showrooms and salesmen.

By Fara Warner, WSJ Interactive Edition
May 17, 1999 5:46 AM PT

A new Internet venture backed by computer executive Michael Dell's personal-investment firm and co-founded by idealab Chairman Bill Gross plans to become the first company to sell cars entirely through the Internet, bypassing showrooms and salesmen the way Inc. bypasses bookstores.

The venture, called, promises to heat up competition among auto makers, online-buying services and dealer groups such as AutoNation Inc., which are scrambling to control the growing number of consumers who go online to shortcut the traditional process of shopping for new and used vehicles.

Have an opinion on this story? Add your comments to the bottom of the page., which already has sold $20 million of cars through a test Web site since December, is launching its updated Web site this month and plans to begin buying dealerships later this year, company executives say.

Eliminating the middlemen
Unlike other third-party online car companies, such as Inc. or Microsoft Corp.'s CarPoint, doesn't funnel sales leads to dealers. In fact, consumers never have to talk to a dealer if they so choose. Instead, CarsDirect immediately gives consumers a set price online based on recent average selling prices. It works through existing dealers to get the car at those prices.


Downloads: Chess software

Would you buy a car online?

Consumers, who pay a credit-card deposit of $250 to start the process, can use CarsDirect to apply for financing through Bank One Corp.'s subsidiary Finance One. The subsidiary is signing a partnership with CarsDirect to create an online auto-financing venture. Finance One's existing network of about 10,000 dealers also will be used as a source of vehicles for CarsDirect. In the end, CarsDirect will deliver vehicles to buyers' homes or offices and even put its own brand on the back of the car.

'The auto business is probably the biggest retail segment in the world, but the direct model through the Internet has never really been applied to it before.'
-- Glenn Fuhrman, managing principal at MSD Capital LP

"The auto business is probably the biggest retail segment in the world, but the direct model through the Internet has never really been applied to it before," said Glenn Fuhrman, managing principal at MSD Capital LP, which invests Dell's private funds and has taken a stake in CarsDirect. "People said they were doing it, but nobody really was."

Gross, who sits on CarsDirect's board, said that even when CarsDirect buys dealerships it "plans to close them down. We'll keep the land, but we won't have people on the showroom floor." Gross said the company already has $25 million in capital to begin acquiring dealerships. Gross's idealab, a venture incubator, has also backed eToys and among other Internet-retailing sites.

CarsDirect has also attracted other big-name backers, including Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and automotive publisher Primedia Ventures.

Watch out Detroit
"Detroit's going to be scared," said James McQuivey, senior analyst with Forrester Research in Cambridge, Mass., who wrote a report predicting such a company would be created. "Everywhere I go, people always ask if we could do the Dell model in cars and when is it going to happen." Dell Computer Co., founded by Dell, sells computers direct to consumers through the Internet.

Front Page
Tech Center
Money and Investing
Subscribe to

But CarsDirect faces big hurdles. The company said it will be able to deliver cars anywhere in the country, but that means in many cases it will have to work through a tangle of state laws that govern car sales. It's also still only in the early stages of setting up a dealer network. AutoNation, the biggest auto retailer in the country, already has a national network and plans to sell $500 million of cars over the Web this year. Manufacturers also are forging ahead with their own sales on the Internet and will balk at cooperating with yet another third party trying to steal car sales online.

Chris Denove, director of consulting operations at J.D. Power and Associates, cautions that CarsDirect must keep its prices low. But that won't be easy since prices fluctuate as manufacturers and dealers raise and lower discounts. CarsDirect's co-founder and Chief Executive Officer Scott Painter said the company will keep prices in the lowest 10% of the range for given models. Initially, Painter said the company would even subsidize the price of a car to stay competitive.

"In the long-term, we think large volumes are going to help us make more money on the cars," he said. The company, which doesn't add service fees to the price of its cars, plans to sell vehicles at an "average" price for a given area and squeeze profits out of volume discounts from dealers. CarsDirect also plans to generate revenue from other services it offers, such as financing, maintenance and insurance, he said.

Will consumers commit?
"There's also a risk that consumers will be reluctant to commit to as costly a purchase as a car with just the click of a mouse.

"Three years ago, we were convinced that selling cars directly to the consumer online was the right model," said Alex Simons, group product manager for Microsoft CarPoint. "But we got overwhelming negative responses from them. They said they like the local presence."

Still, a number of auto makers are pursuing ventures that bring them ever closer to selling cars to consumers via the Internet. Ford Motor Co., through its minority interest in the Tulsa Auto Collection retail network, Tulsa, Okla., is selling Ford Mustangs on the Internet. And Toyota Motor Corp.'s U.S. sales arm is considering testing a new version of its Web site that offers a look at the company's inventory, said June Okamoto, the U.S. division's Internet marketing manager. But Okamoto said dealers remain a big part of the selling process.

Dealers who have worked with CarsDirect said they still feel as if they are a part of the process, especially when it comes to service. "We are getting consumers who are ready to buy and they are going to be long-term customers," said Ryan Autrey, dealer principal at Long Beach BMW, in Long Beach, Calif. He said he has sold about 14 cars through CarsDirect since January and has the same number on order.

See also: ZDNN's Internet section

YOu forgot to mention trade-ins... - Dennis Jackson
Now Illegal in Georgia! Our wo... - Michael Tavel
Getting off the ground is not t... - Bernie Atutis
There's a better way to sell/bu... - Sam Conklin
Didn't Autobytel do this about ... - Jason
In the end, what is the ultimat... - Howard Parr
I don't think Georgia has the p... - Albert Grimes
Howard, did you know that the r... - Bill Tecklen
The concept is a good one in th... - Tracy Brohard
Buying direct would be just one... - Roger
They have technical difficultie... - Matthew Taylor
Fantastic idea and Dell can mak... - david sykes
I just bought a car from these ... - Jack Olexy
I hope the cars dell sells are ... - gary elliott
One problem that stands out is ... - Johh Ligthart
People are indeed afraid of buy... - Sean Warden
Who sets the "average" selling ... - Dick Kaufman
Dealers are already beating the... - Keith Pettersen
Dear cardirect; If this id... - verle stockdale
You are misleading the public. ... - C R GOAD
Oh please Howard. Sales peop... - Kevin von Boro
I am in the market and ready to... - Connie Acton
The site is prom... - Steve Wolf
I am one of those touchy, feely... - John Himes
Are CarsDirect's cars cheaper? ... - Andrew Galarneau
I wonder how you're going to te... - Kurt
I'll use anything that loses th... - Keith Thompson
This must have really been good... - stuart simpson
Car dealers are just lawyers an... - James
Well, well, talk about a pig in... - Willis Russell
Hey I am all for it. What abou... - Jeannette
What about response times to cu... - Michael Braun
tried the site yesterday, full ... - Doug Baker
For some great new car deals ch... - Tony
Dealerships are an internet pur... - John Duncan
Can an Internet sale of your ne... - Gary Dunford
Dell just settled deceptive sal... - Dale